Description
Book SynopsisThe delict of iniuria is among the most sophisticated products of the Roman legal tradition. The original focus of the delict was assault, although iniuria-literally a wrong or unlawful act-indicated a very wide potential scope. Yet it quickly grew to include sexual harassment and defamation, and by the first century CE it had been re-oriented around the concept of contumelia so as to incorporate a range of new wrongs, including insult and invasion of privacy. In truth, it now comprised all attacks on personality. It is the Roman delict of iniuria which forms the foundation of both the South African and-more controversially-Scots laws of injuries to personality. On the other hand, iniuria is a concept formally alien to English law. But as its title suggests, this book of essays is representative of a species of legal scholarship best described as 'oxymoronic comparative law', employing a concept peculiar to one legal tradition in order to interrogate another where, apparently, it does not belong. Addressing a series of doctrinal puzzles within the law of assault, defamation and breach of privacy, it considers in what respects the Roman delict of iniuria overlaps with its modern counterparts in England, Scotland and South Africa; the differences and similarities between the analytical frameworks employed in the ancient and modern law; and the degree to which the Roman proto-delict points the way to future developments in each of these three legal systems.
Trade Review[An] admirable volume which contains eleven excellent essays...a most rewarding source of information [and] a considerable pleasure to read. -- Geoffrey MacCormack * The Edinburgh Law Review *
The book bristles with stimulating analysis that shows the sometimes surprising interaction of Roman, South African, Scots and English law. -- Ken Oliphant * Yearbook of European Tort Law *
[T]his is a well-presented book which reports an interesting seminar that has achieved its goal... -- Tammo Wallinga * Roman Legal Tradition, Volume 10 *
Table of Contents1. Iniuria and the Common Law Eric Descheemaeker and Helen Scott 2. Iniuria, Roman and English David Ibbetson 3. The actio iniuriarum in Scots Law: Romantic Romanism or Tool for Today? Kenneth McKenzie Norrie 4. Solatium and Injury to Feelings: Roman Law, English Law and Modern Tort Theory Eric Descheemaeker 5. Dissimulatio Paul Mitchell 6. Contumelia and the South African Law of Defamation Helen Scott 7. An Infringement of the corpus as a Form of iniuria: Roman and Medieval Reflections Paul J du Plessis 8. The Protection of corpus in Modern and Early Modern Scots Law John Blackie 9. The Gist of Defamation in South African Law Anton Fagan 10. Retraction, Apology and Reply as Responses to iniuriae Jonathan Burchell 11. Harassment: A Wrong without a Right? François du Bois
