Description
Book SynopsisTrade ReviewIf torture is so ineffective as an interrogation tool, producing unreliable information while spurring opposition recruitment and losing hearts and minds, why does it persist in liberal democracies that have clearly outlawed it? In this historically rich book, William d'Ambruoso addresses this paradox by examining the US government's use of torture over a century—from the Philippine-American War through the Vietnam conflict to the post-September 11 'war on terror.' He incisively shows how the allure of the prohibited (if it's banned, it must work, right?) and the vagueness of the prohibition (what exactly is torture, anyway?) contribute to a stubborn willingness in extraordinary circumstances to deploy a horrendous tool that its architects must know is both counterproductive and antithetical to the values that they purport to uphold. * Kenneth Roth, Executive Director, Human Rights Watch *
d'Ambruoso's work provides a historically rich account of the USA's use of torture from the late 1800s to the war on terror. He demonstrates the fragility of the anti-torture norm and provides a compelling argument for unequivocal definitions of torture, to help buttress the norm, and to facilitate accountability of elected officials who are responsible for upholding international human rights law, as well as the most fundamental of human rights. * Ruth Blakeley, University of Sheffield *
A concise, engaging volume that will be a must-read for scholars of armed conflict. Tracing US reliance on torture from war in the Philippines, to Vietnam, to the contemporary war on terror, d'Ambruoso achieves a remarkable feat: a crisply stated theoretical argument that nevertheless rejects false parsimony. Examining key decision moments across three conflicts, he explains the puzzling persistence of an atrocity that both courts international opprobrium and (often) fails to achieve its ostensible goals. The conflicts d'Ambruoso foregrounds are well known, yet d'Ambruoso brings new perspectives to the comparison—a significant feat. * Amelia Hoover Green, Drexel University *
Table of ContentsChapter 1: Torture and the Norm against It: Undying Rivals Chapter 2: Liberal-Democratic Torture: Answered and Unanswered Questions Chapter 3: The Search for "Nasty" but "Safe" Interrogation Methods Chapter 4: Justifying Torture in the Philippine-American War Chapter 5: The Roots and Rationalizations of U.S. Torture in Vietnam Chapter 6: Twenty-First Century Torture: The War on Terror Chapter 7: Conclusion
