Description
Book Synopsis
Who can lay claim to a legally-recognized Indian identity? Who decides whether or not an individual qualifies? The right to determine tribal citizenship is fundamental to tribal sovereignty, but deciding who belongs has a complicated history, especially in the South.Indians who remained in the South following removal became a marginalized and anomalous people in an emerging biracial world. Despite the economic hardships and assimilationist pressures they faced, they insisted on their political identity as citizens of tribal nations and rejected Euro-American efforts to reduce them to another racial minority, especially in the face of Jim Crow segregation. Drawing upon their cultural traditions, kinship patterns, and evolving needs to protect their land, resources, and identity from outsiders, southern Indians constructed tribally-specific citizenship criteria, in part by manipulating racial categories - like blood quantum - that were not traditional elements of indigenous cultures. Mik
Trade Review
A much-needed exploration of the complexities and stresses that Native nations face in their efforts to maintain control over citizenship and national identity within their communities.Who Belongs? is a wonderfully detailed testament to the many complexities of identity, community, territory, and cultural connectivity that constitute not just the Native nations explored in this text but also others spreadacross Indian country.It is a valuable addition to the historiography of the Native South, to critical identity and race studies in the United States, and to the wider canon of federal Indian law and American Indian sovereignty. * Paul McKenzie-Jones, Journal of Southern History *
Adams has taken on an incredible task in chronicling the histories of six tribes from colonialism to citizenship, and readers will appreciate the legal ethnohistory of tribal citizenship practices she offers * Katrina Jagodinsky, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Journal of American Ethnic Hisory *
Adams has authored a wonderful study of citizenship and belonging in the Native South. The book is well conceived, thoroughly researched, and lucidly written. Her arguments are clearly outlined in the introduction and cleverly tied together in the conclusion. In between she effectively illustrates how six southern tribal nations strategically acted to define and protect their identity in the twentieth century. Scholarship on southern Indians in the post-removal era is flourishing, and this book is a significant contribution to the field. * Christopher Arris Oakley, North Carolina Historical Review *
Mikaela Adams has produced a very original, well-researched, and badly needed study of citizenship and sovereignty in the modern Native American South....Her narrative is carefully crafted and the stories lively. Her usage of the available sources is comprehensive. Most important, the issues of nationhood, citizenship, and sovereignty that she grapples with swirl today in Native communities, and as more scholars begin to reevaluate Native American history of all eras, this book will prove incredibly insightful. * Kevin Kokomoor, H-AmIndian *
This is a stunning piece of scholarship on Native identity. By understanding Native communities in the South through the lenses of sovereignty and self-determination, this book upends old approaches and makes a vital contribution to our understanding of Native histories and cultures. It places their voices and experiences first, reminding us that those communities have never ceded control of their own narratives. * Clyde Ellis, author of A Dancing People: Powwow Culture on the Southern Plains *
Written in clear and engaging prose, Adams provides a sweeping analysis of the politics of belonging among six indigenous nations of the American South. The research is staggering in its breadth. But the discussion of each tribe's strategy in defining citizenship is still deeply attentive to local circumstances, showing the convergent and divergent ways in which Native peoples negotiated race, religion, resources, and relationships as they defined and refined their nationhood. It is an essential read in studies of the Native South. * Angela Pulley Hudson, author of Real Native Genius: How an Ex-Slave and a White Mormon became Famous Indians *
In compelling fashion, Who Belongs? reveals the complicated chemistry and history behind the contemporary struggles over tribal citizenship. Contemporary Indian tribes are free to choose their own qualifications for membership, but Adams deftly shows us how different cultural and political terrains have led Natives to choose differently. This is an important and timely book and one that will undoubtedly shape the future of tribal sovereignty. * Andrew K. Frank, author of Creeks and Southerners: Biculturalism on the Early American Frontier *
Adams's prose is readable and engaging as she interweaves complex, theoretical principles with accessible examples."-Jeff Fortney, Ethnohistory
As anyone who has studied citizenship definitions in modern North American Indian tribes knows, Adams has taken on a topic rife with a constantly shifting matrix of rules, regulations, criteria and transformations that boggle the mind and defy easy understanding....Adams's signature accomplishment is addressing tribal citizenship criteria in the modern South in a clear, relatively concise way that addresses a glaring regional gap in Native American historiography....Who Belongs? is a significant contribution to scholarship on the Native South that effectively addresses a difficult issue vital to both the past and present. This work should be used by scholars and teachers alike to provide a different perspective on native peoples in the South that treats them not as historical relics but as resourceful modern groups and individuals who continue to navigate impediments to community survival successfully.>"-Daniel S. Murphree, History
Adams skillfully combines an ethnohistorical take on the evolving conception of race with legal scholarship to present an argument that tribal citizenship, shaped by notions of belonging and practical economic and political concerns, is necessarily dynamic as a response to American intervention....A worthy read for those in history and ethnic studies."-Alaina E. Roberts, Western Historical Quarterly
A much-needed exploration of the complexities and stresses that Native nations face in their efforts to maintain control over citizenship and national identity within their communities. In an era when these nations are again threatened by federal and congressional attempts to subvert their sovereignty in order to gain access to extractable fuel on reservations and Native lands, this text is a timely reminder of the legal and political strength of that sovereignty in matters as apparently straightforward as defining one's own citizenry....Using oral histories and an impressive number of archival collections, Adams seamlessly blends tribal, settler, and state histories with an impressive analysis of federal Indian law to provide an exhaustively researched examination of the contours and strictures of belonging that have framed identity and community within these six Native nations."-Paul McKenzie-Jones, Journal of Southern History
Tribal citizenship is not a static concept; rather, Native peoples have used citizenship in a variety of ways: to assert a particular identity, to protect resources, or to push back against the segregation of the Jim Crow South....Adams's careful analysis shows how tribes have defined Indian identity as a political status based on citizenship in a particular group, rather than race, and the consequences that then follow."-Fay A. Yarbrough, American Historical Review
Adams's research is thorough, her analysis insightful, and her story rather ironic. The introductory chapter...is a model for how historians ought to open an argument."-Tim Alan Garrison, Pacific Historical Review
Adams draws evidence from a range of ethnographic, tribal, state, and federal sources. Each one of these chapters could be its own book, and yet her concise, detailed treatment of the five case studies is comprehensive and nuanced....This book will be a welcome addition to classes on the histories of Native peoples, the South, and race. A strength is Adams's pivot between policy and personal stories. She infuses the book with just enough genealogy to provide a human face to decisions that often had less to do with relationships than with protecting resources; asserting sovereignty; or, in the case of the federal government, just finishing the job....This book is essential reading for anyone who wants to understand Native Southerners today."-Rose Stremlau, Journal of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era
An essential and ongoing conversation about the historical and contemporary challenges to indigenous sovereignty and self-determination."-Brandi Hilton-Hagemann, Reviews in American History
Table of Contents
Acknowledgments Introduction: Citizenship and Sovereignty Chapter 1: Policing Belonging, Protecting Identity: The Pamunkey Indian Tribe of Virginia Chapter 2: From Fluid Lists to Fixed Rolls: The Catawba Indian Nation of South Carolina Chapter 3: Learning the Language of "Blood": The Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians Chapter 4: Contests of Sovereignty: The Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Chapter 5: Nation Building and Self-Determination: The Seminole Tribe of Florida and the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians of Florida Conclusion: Who Belongs? Notes Bibliography Index
