Description
Book SynopsisThe title is an allusion to the description by Suger, Abbot of St. Denis, of the men of the Auvergne. Suger depicts "that old pride" in a chapter of his Deeds of Louis the Fat, which chronicles the arrival of King Louis VI in the region (1122 and 1126), to succor Eimeric I, the Bishop of Clermont, obliged to flee his episcopal town after its seizure by the Count of Auvergne. The citation provides a frame of reference for the subject of this study: the Auvergnat laity and its relations with the Church as they can be deduced from the abundant representations of secular figures in Romanesque Auvergne.
A wide-ranging interdisciplinary approach is brought into play in dealing with the art historical, historical, social, political, legal, theological, and liturgical aspects of the theme. The first three chapters treat the various contexts in which secular characters appear. Chapter 1 distinguishes between two series, of lay donors and of avaricious persons, Chapter 2 discusses figures of warriors in enigmatic contexts in the churches of Brioude and Riom-ès-Montagnes. Chapter 3 is concerned with non-noble figures, namely a group of rustic shepherds. Chapter 4 examines the ecclesiastical condition in the province through a case study of the monastic community of Mozac.
The description of the peculiarities of Auvergnat Romanesque sculpture, and the inquiry into the imagery as a product of the rival forces of Church and laity, offers a new reading of such matters as property, social hierarchy, law, liturgy, and theology, as they are reflected in stone. The unrecorded past of the figures in various contexts of giving or of indulging in avarice, war, and bloodshed, is perhaps compensated by this sculptural abundance.
Table of ContentsIntroduction
1 "That Old Pride of the Men of the Auvergne"
Lay Donors in Auvergnat Romanesque Sculpture: Visual Analysis
The Patron Couple of Bulhon
The Patron Couple of Thuret
The Patron Couple of Trizac
Guillelmes at Volvic
Stephanus at Notre-Dame-du-Port in Clermont
Ranulfus at St. Nectaire
The Founding Inscription at Mozac
The Deadly Sin of Avarice in Auvergnat Romanesque Sculpture: Visual Analysis
Charity Meets Avarice: Donation as Mediator in Property Relations of the Diocese of Clermont (c. 1030 - c. 1151) The Inventive Pictorial Scheme of Lay Donation in Auvergne
2 The Bellicose Auvergnats: Warlike scenes in the Church of St. Julien at Brioude (Haute-Loire)
Warlike Scenes in the Church of St. Georges at Riom-ès-Montagnes (Cantal)
3 Good or Bad Shepherds in Auvergne: Social Metamorphosis of an Ancient Motif
4 Tradition Meets Innovation: The Case of St. Pierre at Mozac (Puy-de-Dôme)
The Monastic Portal: Ecclesiastical Donor Iconography
The Reliquary Box of Saint Calmin: An Obscure Donor of the Past
5 Conclusion
6 Appendix: History of Auvergnat Churches with Donation Scenes
Bibliography
Illustrations
Index
