Description
Book SynopsisThe collective work deals with the problems of if, how, and why the histories of German Nazism and Soviet Communism should and could be situated within one coherent narrative. As historical phenomena, can Communism and Nazism fruitfully be compared to each other? Do they belong to the same historical contexts? Have they influenced, reacted to or learned from each other? Are they interpreted, represented and used together by posterity? The background of the book is twofold. One is external. There is an ongoing debate about the historical entanglements of Communism and Nazism, especially about Auschwitz and Gulag, respectively. Our present fascination with the evil history of genocide has situated the Holocaust as the borderline event in Western historical thinking. The crimes against humanity perpetrated by the Soviet Communist regime do not have the same position but are considered more urgent in the East and Central European states that were subdued by both Nazi and Communist regimes.
Trade ReviewPutting the Communist and National Socialist dictatorships side by side as twin models of twentieth-century dystopia has always raised awkward questions about comparability and moral equivalence. The editors and contributors in this fine volume are all too aware of the intellectual challenges involved in equating or comparing the two systems and have provided here a sophisticated and nuanced assessment of their entanglement, not only at the level of historical experience but in terms of the meaning now ascribed to them in historical memory. This is an important milestone in developing a fuller understanding of the special place Communism/National Socialism occupies in contemporary historical culture. -- Richard Overy, University of Exeter
The essays in this volume explore the thorny issues arising in comparative studies of Soviet Communism and German National Socialism. The authors steer a refreshingly independent course that deftly avoids the usual pitfalls in such work, where in the West scholars tend to privilege Hitler and the Holocaust, while most accounts from Eastern Europe highlight the evils of Stalinism. The book’s micro-studies are uniformly excellent, up-to-date, and highly stimulating, and they provide innovative new approaches that should attract a wide readership in academia. -- Robert Gellately, Florida State University, author of Stalin’s Curse: Battling for Communism in War and Cold War
Klas-Göran Karlsson and his Lund University colleagues have edited an important contribution to the growing literature on the intersection between Nazi and Stalinist history and historiography. The volume provides both a state-of-the-art assessment of where this young field is today, as well as fascinating additions to its empirical study. -- Norman Naimark, Stanford University
Table of ContentsIntroduction, Klas-Göran Karlsson, Johan Stenfeldt, and Ulf Zander Chapter One: The Evil Twins of Modern History?: Patterns of Communism-National Socialism Entanglement, Klas-Göran Karlsson Chapter Two: Making Sense of Inhumanity: On the Treatment of an Open Wound in Our History Culture, Jörn Rüsen Chapter Three: The Dystopian Trilemma: The Guiding Potential of the Nazi-Communist Equalization and Strategies Used When Questioning It, Johan Stenfeldt Chapter Four: The Intertwined History of Political Violence in the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany: The Case Study of Helmut Weiss, Anton Weiss-Wendt Chapter Five: Herbert Norkus and Pavel Morozov as Totalitarian Child Martyrs: A Study of Political Religion, Johan Dietsch Chapter Six: Communism’s Compelling Grasp: Enduring the Gulag and Enduring Loyalty, Nanci Adler Chapter Seven: The Lontsky Street Prison Memorial Museum: An Example of Postcommunist Holocaust Negationism, John-Paul Himka Chapter Eight: Writing History, Denying the Past?: On Revisionism, the Holocaust and Soviet Terror, Maria Karlsson
