Description
Book SynopsisA critical survey of a number of philosophical approaches to law and judicial decision-making
Trade Review"A comprehensive assessment of traditional and contemporary legal thought, Mr. Belliotti's defense of 'critical pragmatism' is a significant contribution to the literature. This book takes on all the leading theories and takes them on seriously. It is one of the most ambitious and satisfying efforts in print at mediating the seemingly irreconcilable tensions between law's mainstream liberal analysts and its leftist critics."—
Anita L. Allen, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center
"The author brings a critical intelligence and a very impressive scholarship to traditional issues in law. The strength that jumps from the page is a very well informed contemporary reading that avoids clichés and the limits of much contemporary analysis."—
John Brigham, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, and author of
The Cult of the Court (Temple)
"[A]n excellent survey and analysis of major theories in the philosophy of law. The book features intelligent discussions of such diverse approaches as natural law theory, legal positivism, law and economics, feminist jurisprudence, and Critical Legal Studies. Justifying Law is full of insight, clear reasoning, and common sense.... The wide-ranging examination reveals Belliotti's substantial scholarship and keen intelligence.... Through his presentation and commentary on several philosophies of law and individual legal theorists, Belliotti has enriched and advanced jurisprudential dialogue and inquiry."
—Journal of Value Inquiry
Table of ContentsAcknowledgments Introduction: The Terms of the Debate: Legal Formalism and Legal Realism Part I: The Core of Law: Analytic Jurisprudence 1. The Immanent Moral Order and Law's Objectivity: Natural Law 2. The Quest for Rigor: Legal Positivism 3. The Right Answer Thesis: Ronald Dworkin's Legal Idealism 4. Quantitative Analysis and Circular Apologetics: Law and Economics 5. Reconceiving Rational Constraints: The Interpretivist Turn Part II: What's Left of Law? Challenging Law's Pretensions 6. Historical Necessity and Radical Contingency: Marxist Jurisprudence 7. The Fundamental Contradiction and Nihilism: Critical Legal Studies 8. In Search of Dialogue: Feminism Unmodified Part III: Law's Aspirations and Philosophical Method: Promises, Impasses, and New Directions 9. A Dialogue Between Mainstream Methods and the New Guard: Is There Any Hope? 10. Critical Pragmatism: Pluralism, Justification, and Law's Directive Power Notes Index
