Description
Book SynopsisMichael Lerner collects the greatest Jewish writing of the 1990s in this first volume of a new series. It features pieces on Jewish culture, identity, and spirituality.
Trade ReviewIn this collection of Jewish writing dating from 1994 to 2000, Lerner, the editor of Tikkun magazine, highlights his idea of the politics of meaning and the Jewish religious themes of healing and reconciliation. A wide range of authors (writing fiction, poetry, and essays) discusses questions of Jewish identity, religion, culture, the Holocaust, and Israel. Feminism, gay studies, and environmental concerns are important aspects of the selections. Many well-know authors are included, among them Adrienne Rich, Philip Roth, Yehuda Amichai, Aharon Appelfeld, and Norman Podhoretz. Zalman Schacter Shalomi presents an open and honest attempt to rethink Jewish religious thought, Marge Piercy and Jacqueline Osherow's poems bring new elements to Jewish thinking, and Morris Dickstein describes the changing themes and ideas of writers in the United States. The result is an interesting and diverse anthology. Recommended for Jewish studies collections. (Gene Shaw, NYPL, Library Journal, August 2001)
Whenever my old friend, the curmudgeonly book lover, came across an anthology with a title like "Best Plays" or "Best-Loved Poems," he'd always mutter, "Best? Best? Who says so?" Who, indeed? Why, editors of anthologies claiming "bestness," of course. The editor of "Best Contemporary Jewish Writing" is Rabbi Michael Lerner, editor of Tikkun magazine and himself included in Utne Reader's list of America's "100 Most Important Visionaries."
Continuing his quest for the best, Lerner concludes his collection with a list of "The One Hundred Best Contemporary Jewish Books." So many judgment calls about what's best may well stimulate debate. Still, why quibble? As Lerner explains, this is simply his opinion of what is most significant.
Lerner is a man with a mission, and the mission concerns Jewish spiritual renewal. If large numbers of American Jews in the early and middle decades of the 20th century were breaking loose from their traditional moorings, the last few decades have witnessed, if not quite a return to origins, then certainly a renewed interest among Jews in their religious and cultural heritage. And, indeed, the sheer diversity of voices in this collection, the passion, intelligence and sense of commitment that can be heard are ample evidence of this renewal.
Many kinds of writing have been included: memoirs, essays, literary criticism, fiction and poetry. Sen. Joseph Lieberman describes the origins of his commitment to public life. Moroccan-born Ruth Knafo Setton reflects on her personal experiences as a "Sephardic Jewess" (from the title of her piece). In "Gay and Orthodox," Rabbi Steve Greenberg discusses the dilemmas he has faced trying to reconcile his sexuality with scriptural injunctions against lying with men. Questions of Jewish identity, such as finding the right path between assimilation and distinctness, are addressed in a variety of forms, including an engaging poem by Kenneth Koch and a thoughtful essay by David Biale.
Several pieces by feminists, such as theologian Rachel Adler and novelist Anita Diamant, offer provocative and illuminating interpretations of biblical stories (although Susan Schnur's diatribe against sexism in the Book of Esther is simply obtuse).
On the current literary front, Morris Dickstein surveys contemporary Jewish writers, while Norman Podhoretz has some incisive things to say about Philip Roth and Saul Bellow.
Perhaps the most fascinating material in this book deals with human responsibility toward the natural world. "My commitment to the life of the planet is stronger than my commitment to any philosophy or creed," declares Zalman Schachter-Shalomi, founder of the Jewish Renewal Movement. "If you have felt commanded by the Divine Imperative to protect Earth from planetary destruction, then you have undergone the first stage of a Gaean initiation." Citing Evan Eisenberg's book "The Ecology of Eden" (one of the 100 best on Lerner's list), Arthur Waskow offers an account of the Hebrew religion as a response of humble, freedom-loving Western Semites--shepherds, hunter-gatherers and hill farmers--to the far more regimented, hierarchical world of the Babylonian empire, where a revolution in agricultural technology had created wealth, order and stability, but at the cost of a drastic change in man's relationship to the Earth, to women and to his fellow man.
Two later sections, "Living in the Shadows of the Holocaust" and "Israel in Conflict," are marked by a certain tendentiousness. Although Lerner makes some concession to representing those pushing for the peace process and those who consider it sadly unrealistic, the overall thrust is to lend plausibility to the doves. A triad of essays discussing the Holocaust--by Jonathan Rosen, Zymunt Bauman and Tikkun's associate editor Peter Gabel--makes some interesting points about everything from the film "Schindler's List" to the Nazi mentality. Read in sequence, they function as a kind of three-pronged critique of Jews who (as they see it) use the Holocaust as an "excuse" to justify Israeli hard-line policies.
Jews concerned for their safety and survival having thus been discredited as victims of mass hysteria, the stage is set for Israeli revisionist historian Benny Morris' critique of previous Israeli historians for their tendency to minimize Israel's role in getting Palestinian Arabs to flee their homes during the Israeli War of Independence. Then, for anyone still concerned about the dangers of anti-Semitism--anyone who's been following the venomous goings-on at the soi-disant "anti-racism" (viz. anti-Zionism) U.N. conference in Durban--Jerome Slater notes (rightly, but perhaps no longer all that relevantly) that Palestinian Arabs were not innately anti-Jewish and only became that way after their land was occupied by Israel. (To this, one might say: Nor were Germans overwhelmingly anti-Semitic until they were humiliated at Versailles! To recognize a "root cause" does not necessarily, by itself, enable one to undo the effects.) A grimmer and (sadly, one fears) more realistic view is provided in Daniel Pipes' essay "Land for What?"
Still, there is an optimism, excitement and animation about Lerner's collection that is hard to resist. This volume is the first in a series that is planned to come out each year. It is clearly an auspicious beginning. (By Merle Rubin, LA Times, September 17, 2001)
Table of ContentsIntroduction: Jewish Writing and Healing the World xiii
The Many Identities of a Jew
To Jewishness 3
The Melting Pot and Beyond: Jews and the Politics of American Identity 8
Poems: Reversion and What Kind of Times Are These 15
Justify My Love 17
Ten Ways to Recognize a Sephardic 'Jew-ess' 29
Redemption on East Tremont: The kindness of Christians and a seder's matzah helps the daughter of Mendel Beilis fix the old fears 36
News About Jews 40
Gay and Orthodox 42
Slipping the Punch 55
The Night Game 70
From The Roots of a Public Life 73
From And What Is My Lifespan? 79
Stories: Grandmother Eve, Consecrating the Ordinary, Blessing, and The Reward 80
The Legacy: A Parable About History and Bobe-mayses, Barszcz, and Borscht and the Future of the Jewish Past 86
Reclaiming the Spirit in Judaism
Nishmat 95
Starting on My Spiritual Path 97
On Renewing God 103
Eternity Utters a Day 113
A Kabbalah for the Environmental Age 115
Is God in Trees? 127
The Emergence of Eco-Judaism 134
A Theology of Illness and Healing 145
Death and What's Next 150
Eros and the Ninth of Av 152
From The Book of Jewish Values 155
Poems: Yom Kippur Sonnet and Science Psalm 162
Rereading Sacred Texts of Our Tradition
From And Peace and Justice Shall Kiss 169
From Imagining the Birth of a Nation 186
From The Red Tent 193
From The Bible and You, the Bible and You and Other Midrashim 199
Aaron's God--and Ours: A Yom Kippur Reflection 200
Our (Meaning Women's) Book-of-Esther Problem 205
Living in the Shadows of the Holocaust
Cattle Car Complex 213
Force Fields 221
The Sanctuary 228
The Trivialization of Tragedy 230
Hereditary Victimhood: The Holocaust's Life as a Ghost 241
The Meaning of the Holocaust: Social Alienation and the Infliction of Human Suffering 252
Israel in Conflict
The New Historiography: Israel Confronts Its Past 265
Land for What? 281
Occupation and Antisemitism 284
A Novelist's Optimism: Reclaiming the Jewish Tradition 297
From Booking Passage 300
Poems: From In My Life, On My Life; Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Why Jerusalem?; and The Jewish Time Bomb 323
Hovering at a Low Altitude 326
The Pleasure of Jewish Culture
Making Judaism Cool 331
Old Man 339
Poems: When You Come to Sleep with Me, Come Like My Father and Hebrew 342
Esther and Yochanan 346
The Twenty-seventh Man 352
Against Logic 367
The Healing Power of Jewish Stories 371
The Complex Fate of the Jewish American Writer 375
Bellow at 85, Roth at 67 392
Jewish Writing and the Spiritual Journey: A Speculative Journey 409
The One Hundred Best Contemporary Jewish Books 417
The Editor 423
The Contributors 425
Credits 431
