Description
Book SynopsisDominic Dyer, chief executive of the Badger Trust, picks apart the science and politics behind the badger cull. He exposes the cruelty and cynicism central to Britain's most controversial wildlife policy and clears badgers of blame for rising levels of TB in cattle.
Trade Review'A thriller, whodunnit and impassioned polemic, this is the inside story of the badger cull. A vital must-read for anyone concerned about the badger's enduring place in the British countryside.'
– PATRICK BARKHAM, THE GUARDIAN
'Badgered to Death is a real page turner... the book contains illuminating chapters on the BBC’s pro-badger cull bias, illegal badger persecution by some farmers and the compromised, incoherent support for the cull by the British Veterinary Association.'
– DR DAN LYONS, CENTRE FOR ANIMALS AND SOCIAL JUSTICE, 'How badgers came to be persecuted — but why'
'I enjoyed reading this book and I strongly recommend it to you. This is a powerful and stimulating read and it's bang up to date with the important issue it discusses. It is written by a passionate insider with years of experience. The narrative is pacey and exciting. This book arrived with me on Thursday afternoon and I had read it completely by early yesterday [Saturday] morning.'
– MARK AVERY, WRITER, BLOGGER AND ENVIRONMENTAL CAMPAIGNER
'It should be read by all those battling against government policies that put money ahead of science and the environment. The book's conclusion is that the culls will be stopped, not by science or validity, but by cost. Yet Dyer remains optimistic: 'Despite all the incompetence, negligence and deceit, it's the caring compassionate British public who have made a stand for wildlife that gives me the most hope for the future.'
– LESLEY DOCKSEY, THE ECOLOGIST, 'Why are our badgers 'Badgered to Death'?'
Table of ContentsINTRODUCTION. Wildlife campaigner and Springwatch BBC presenter Chris Packham says that 'the reputation of this essential member of the UK’s ecology [the badger] has been targeted by a smear campaign which has been swallowed by the gullible and fuelled by those with vested interests.'
‘It is very clear to me that the government’s policy does not make sense.’ Lord Robert May, President of the Royal Society and Chief Scientific Advisor, UK Government (1995-2005), speaking in 2012
1. A BLACK AND WHITE NIGHT. Campaigners in 2015 protest at the re-election of Conservative Prime Minister David Cameron in Witney, Oxfordshire, because of his party's policy of culling European badger (Meles meles), ostensibly to reduce Bovine TB in cattle
2. WOVEN INTO THE LANDSCAPE. Most people have never seen a live badger; the closest we tend to come is as we speed past a corpse on the side of the road. However, these large mammals often live in close proximity to us and there are more than 100 manifestations of the Anglo-Saxon 'broc' in place names
3. A DISEASE OF CATTLE. During an outbreak of bovine tuberculosis (TB for short) in cattle at a farm in the Cotswolds Hills scientists found Mycobacterium bovis (bovine TB) in a dead badger. The Government started and then halted gassing badgers. A study showed badgers rarely carried Bovine TB
4. NEW LABOUR. The Labour Party did not support culling. When Tony Blair's New Labour came to power in May 1997 the Ministry of Agriculture introduced a moratorium on new badger culls. The Krebs report recommended that MAFF set up an experiment to quantify the impact on Bovine TB of culling badgers
5. GORDON BROWN VETOES A CULL. In 2001, Tony Blair created the Department of the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), which inherited higher bovine TB cases. A review by Professor Bourne of the Krebs randomised trials found only 1.65% of badgers could spread TB to cattle
6. CAMERON'S CULL. In the run up to the 2010 general election, when every rural vote would count, and with commitments already made to the NFU and Countryside Alliance to deliver a badger cull, David Cameron and his farming spokesman Jim Paice hailed a report by Chief Scientific Advisor Sir David King
7. WILDLIFE OVER BUSINESS. A chance encounter on a suburban street in Kingston upon Thames made up the author's mind to ditch corporate lobbying and campaign full-time, already being chairman of Care for the Wild, a wildlife protection charity. He first saw badgers on the Isle of Wight
8. AWKWARD FACTS. New DEFRA Secretary of State Owen Paterson Paterson made it very clear that he would not be pushed off course by growing public, political and scientific opposition to the badger cull. Bovine TB had led to the slaughter of 26,000 cattle the previous year, he told MPs
9. THE BADGER ARMY. Protests were organised nationwide. The informal "Badger Army" had become the largest wildlife protection campaign in Britain and elicited political interest as well as media headlines. After each march photos and videos were shared on Twitter, Facebook and other social media
10. GREEN MOVEMENT FAILS THE BADGER. While ordinary people across the country have protested against the badger cull, there has been a marked lack of action from the major conservation and wildlife protection NGOs. Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth, WWF, World Animal Protection have done almost nothing
11. DEFENDED BY AMATEURS. With the support of other key wildlife protection charities opposing the cull, the Badger Trust challenged the wide-ranging nature of an anti-protect injunction and its impact on the right to peaceful protest at the High Court
12. BBC BIAS. As the badger cull progressed the BBC became heavily criticised by the badger protection movement. In my view, some of this was unfair, particularly as its regional networks had given extensive coverage of the badger protection patrols in the culling zones. But in some cases, the BBC failed
13. ILLEGAL CULLS. Today in Britain badgers are regularly killed by farmers, landowners, hunt masters, game keepers, property developers, badger baiters and a variety of sick individuals, who gain some perverted pleasure from subjecting wildlife to pain and suffering
14. TB BURGERS. Whenever the media reports the number of TB cattle slaughtered, they often state the animals have been destroyed, leaving the public with the impression the carcasses are incinerated to prevent them from entering the food chain. But this is not so
15. OWEN PATERSON. Within months of arriving at Defra in September 2012, Paterson had caused controversy by refusing to meet his Chief Scientific Advisor, Ian Boyd – and for claiming at the Conservative Party conference that there could be advantages to climate change
16. VETS' DILEMMA. The new Defra Secretary Liz Truss made no attempt to explain why none of the badgers killed in the culls was being tested for TB and became visibly nervous when we talked of the £5,000 per dead badger cost to the taxpayer. Defra Chief Vet Nigel Gibbens did not attend the meeting
17. COST OF THE CULL. By the end of 2013 Defra, which had seen its operating budget cut by over £900 million and was laying off hundreds of staff, confirmed that in 2011/12 it had spent £6.3 million of its £2.2 billion budget killing 1,879 badgers in Gloucestershire and Somerset – £3,350 per badger
18. FARMING FUTURE. As dairy farms face collapse due to falling milk prices, farmers are increasingly supplementing their income by moving and selling calves and cows, often with poor biosecurity, testing and movement controls, which can increase the spread of bovine TB
19. FATE OF THE BADGER. Farmers in the UK are also becoming increasingly frustrated by the failure of the government and the NFU to help them reduce bovine TB. Rather than the endless battle over the killing of badgers, many are now openly calling for an alternative strategy
20. BADGER VOICES. Profiles of influential campaigners: TV presenter Chris Packham, Queen guitarist Brian May, TV presenter Bill Oddie, documentary maker Simon King, Guardian writer Patrick Barkham, Sunday Times writer Jonathan Leake, zoologist Martin Hancox, Badger Trust's Peter Martin, vet Mark Jones
21. INDEX. Such as the As: Aberdeen University, Advertising Standards Authority, Advisory Committee on Microbiological Safety of Food, Africa, Agriculture Act, Alaska, Allen Caroline, alpaca, Amchitka, American bullfrog, Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency, Attenborough, Sir David King
DEDICATION. This book is dedicated to the memory of Clare Hammacott, who died on 28th December 2016
ABOUT THE AUTHOR. After 13 years as a civil servant in MAFF, in 2000 he joined the Food and Drink Federation. In 2008 he became chief executive of the Crop Protection Association. In 2012, he became a campaigner. He is a policy advisor for the Born Free Foundation and chief executive of the Badger Trust
